Monday, May 09, 2005

good governance or "elections"?

in my humble opinion something has to give.in the 21st century and in an ever shrinking world, can a nation afford to spend years forming a stable democracy?will such an endeavour not lead to short term political instability?hence potentially harming economic growth.in a developing third world country isnt economic growth more of a priority?i feel that economic growth that leads to a betterment in the standard of living will inevitably lead to political freedom and democracy.economic growth will mean more people coming out of poverty,more people going to schools and universities and more people being exposed to the globalised environment.basically people becoming better voters.people becoming aware of their rights. in stead of politicians preying on for lack of a better word ignorant or helpless voters, politicians will have to earn their power.in pakistan this is exactly what is needed; good governance.forget elections or the sham politicians.just focus on delievering prosperity to the masses and see how in 15 years we will have a flourishing political arena.as long as the judiciary is not independent as it is in say india and as long as we have politicians worse than anywhere else in the world then lets just focus on achieving economic growth.china in a few years will have its elections.it is inevitable. but when in the future people read history they'll find out it was the communist party that gave prosperity to millions.it was a south korean dictatorship that changed the face of korea.it was mahathir's one man rule in malaysia that made malaysia and it was one party rule in japan that made japan.a benevolent dictator is better than our democracy.the hypocrisy is that the parties themselves arent democratic.do we have to endure cult based politics.for how long and to what end.?i apologise for my incoherent rambling.in conclusion i feel it is unfair to me a 24 year old growing up in pakistan and it is unfair to future generations to keep on having elections where the same people show up in parliaments and do nothing but plunder and terrorise.i for one do not buy the theory that if parliaments are allowed to finish their terms or if the electoral process is allowed to continue sooner or later things will work out.maybe they will maybe they wont.we dont have time to find out.so why not go the alternative route.the asian route.the successful route.finally there is no set roadmap.there is no law.there are only theories.India is a very rare example of a third world democracy achieving economic prosperity.but then all the Asean countries and china presently were not a democracy and look at what theyve acheived.

5 Comments:

Blogger Muneeba Omar said...

Jarrar, I just read your post and completely agree with you. In fact I just wrote my honours thesis which is titled "Pakistan: Stability First, Democracy Second," and your post is basically a summary of what I argued. It's refreshing to find that other people share my views. I also feel that what we had in Pakistan under Benazir and Nawaz can be more accurately defined as electocracies rather than democraciess. I am just finishing up my undergrad in Canada and from what I read here, I get the over all impression that conditions in Pakistan are improving under Musharraf and perhaps a soft-authoritarianism is more suitable for a country like Pakistan. I also agree with you in that democracy must give way to the imperative of economic development and that development lays the foundation for democracy. Look at it in terms of Maslow's hierarchy of needs, people will only worry about social issues and democratic reform once their lowel needs of hunger and safety have been satisfied. Sorry for these long comments, your post echoed exactly what I have been busting my ass over for the past 10 months that I couldn't resist.

7:41 AM

 
Blogger Muneeba Omar said...

I don't know if you are familiar with Fareed Zakaria, but his book "The Future of Freedom" definitely affected my outlook towards different forms of government. I don't know if that would be available in Pakistan but you could definitely find his article "The Rise of Illiberal Democracy" at his website www.fareedzakaria.com This guy is brilliant. Okay, enough, I'll stop harrassing you.

8:06 AM

 
Blogger Jerry shah said...

thank you so much for your comments.finally there is someone out there who knows what im talking about.you're right about the 90's governments.ive read fareed's book.he his brilliant.hope you got an A for your thesis.

11:45 AM

 
Blogger Muneeba Omar said...

Hey no problem, it is a pleasure to read your blog. I thought I didn't know any body who cared. The thesis is being marked as we speak. But we should definitely discuss politics sometimes, and if you are interested I'll give you a copy of my thesis in Lahore. It's been accepted for publishing so I am in the process of editing it, but it will go under my prof's name b/c I'm the second author on it - go figure. But I agree with you that this obsession with democracy, especially in the West, is really bullshit. In fact, "democracy" has become so hallowed a concept that most people today have accepted it as a universally desirable goal. Just as human being does not come into the world fully formed and at its best capabilities, neither do new born countries, which are severely lacking in social, political and legal institutions which are imperative in order to sustain democratic rule. Even in terms of literature in the West, all they talk about is democracy and how democracy is good and democracy brings peace. You will never find any pro-authoritarian literature which is quite sad b/c it has worked wonders in East Asia. I really think that there should be shift in academics and intellectuals support of democracy b/c they go out of their way to diss soft authoritarianism (I read a bunch of articles about how authoritarian rule was resposnsible for the Asian Economic Crisis. Give me a break for chrissake. Until we have economic prosperity, democracy is an unaffordable luxury for Pakistan. Btw, I enjoy reading your blog so I will be leave you comments on your Pakistani politics/media blogs. Keep writing.

6:40 AM

 
Blogger Jerry shah said...

i'd love to have a copy of your publication.definetly politics session is a must:)see you soon.

3:03 PM

 

Post a Comment

<< Home